Gabriel & Co. Review: Is Gabriel & Co. Legit? Trust Check (November 2026)

Q: Does Gabriel & Co. ship to Canada?

Not from gabrielny.com, which ships only to US addresses; Canadian customers order through gabrielny.ca and pay import duties, customs fees and provincial taxes. US standard shipping is free and takes 3 to 5 business days for ready-to-ship items, with an adult signature.

By the Trusted Jewelries team · Published Nov 2, 2026 · Updated Nov 2, 2026 · Facts checked Nov 2, 2026 · How we check stores

66Trust Score

Mostly reliable

See the breakdown

Our verdict

A family-run New York jewelry designer and manufacturer founded in 1989 — free shipping with an adult signature, 30 days to return with free return shipping and a lifetime warranty against defects once you register the piece, but the site names no legal company, the warranty's terms aren't published, and a couple of stone names don't match their pages.

Visit Gabriel & Co.

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes the score. How we make money

Best for

Buyers of diamond fine jewelry who want free signed-for shipping, free returns and a lifetime warranty against defects^1,2,3

Not ideal for

Anyone who wants to read a warranty’s full terms before buying^1,2,3,4,5
Shoppers who want to buy an engagement ring with its center diamond online: rings are sold as settings, by appointment⁶

The bottom line. Gabriel & Co. was founded in New York in 1989 by the brothers Jack and Dominick Gabriel, and Jack Gabriel is its CEO^7,8; it runs its own manufacturing facility and sells through authorized retailers as well as on its own website³. Online orders ship free with an adult signature¹, can be returned within 30 days of delivery for a refund with complimentary return shipping^1,2, and get a free lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects once registered³. You pay by credit card, and the checkout code also includes PayPal and Klarna^9,10; its New York location is rated 4.8 on Google from 360 reviews¹¹. It isn’t scored higher because the site names no legal company^{1,2,3,5,7,9,12}, the warranty’s terms and conditions aren’t published^1,2,3,4,5, shipping insurance and lost parcels aren’t addressed^1,2,5,9, resizing isn’t mentioned^{1,2,3,4,5,9,13}, and some stone names don’t match: one page’s address calls its sapphire ‘synthetic’ while the page doesn’t¹⁴, and a cuff listed with a ‘Black Pearl’ is described as black mother pearl¹⁵.

What we like

A free lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects, plus a year’s cover for wear and tear or accidental damage, once the piece is registered within 30 days³
Free shipping, with an adult signature on every order¹
30 days from delivery to return for a refund to your original payment, with complimentary return shipping^1,2
Free inspection and cleaning every six months at participating retailers³
Founders named on the site, and its own manufacturing facility^3,8
Diamond pages give total weight and average clarity and color, and say the diamonds are verified by GIA as natural^16,17
Most bridal and fashion pieces made from 100% recycled gold; diamonds under the Kimberley Process²
Phone, email and live chat⁵

Watch out for

No legal company named on the site^{1,2,3,5,7,9,12}
The warranty’s terms and conditions are referred to but not published, so its exclusions are unknown^1,2,3,4,5
Shipping insurance and lost or stolen parcels aren’t addressed^1,2,5,9
Stone names don’t always match: one page’s address calls its sapphire ‘synthetic’ but the page doesn’t, and black mother pearl is listed as ‘Black Pearl’^14,15
No resizing service mentioned^{1,2,3,4,5,9,13}
Engagement rings are sold as settings only, by appointment at retailers^5,6
Trustpilot shows 3 out of 5 from only 2 reviews¹⁸

How we checked Gabriel & Co.. On Nov 2, 2026 we read 26 pages of Gabriel & Co.’s website — policies, FAQ, terms, warranty and contact pages — plus 20 product pages, and saved a copy of each. All 74 facts in this review come from those copies or from the other sources listed at the end, and each one was checked against its saved source before publishing. We also looked at the domain registration record, Trustpilot and Reddit.

On this page

At a glance Trust Score breakdown Who is behind Gabriel & Co.How to reach Gabriel & Co.Returns & exchanges Shipping & delivery Warranty & aftercare What Gabriel & Co. sells & what it costs Payment & financing What customers say Gabriel & Co. FAQ Update history Sources

Other stores we’ve checked

Shane Co.78/100 · TrustworthyFamily-owned US jeweler since 1929: engagement rings, diamonds, pearls · Visit

Keyzar78/100 · TrustworthyEngagement rings with lab-grown or natural diamonds · Visit

Grown Brilliance76/100 · TrustworthyLab-grown diamond engagement rings and fine jewelry, online or in its stores · Visit

Plum Diamonds73/100 · Mostly reliableLab-grown diamond engagement rings from Chicago, made in its own workshops, with free lifetime care · Visit

Monica Vinader71/100 · Mostly reliableBritish gold-vermeil and recycled-silver jewelry with 100-day returns and a 5-year warranty · Visit

Gabriel & Co. policies at a glance

Return window	30 days from delivery; exchanges ordered within 30 days of purchase; engagement rings: one exchange within a year (Shop Confidently)^1,4
Return shipping	Complimentary, with a prepaid UPS label (values page); the returns page speaks of 'pre-paid postage' and suggests insuring the parcel^1,2
Can't be returned	Used pieces, unless defective¹
Refund	To the original payment, after inspection; 5–7 business days after it arrives¹
Warranty	Lifetime against manufacturing defects; one year for wear and accidental damage; register within 30 days; written terms not published³
Resizing	Not mentioned on the pages we read^{1,2,3,4,5,9,13}
Shipping	Free standard, 3–5 business days (made-to-order about 2 weeks); adult signature; insurance not mentioned^1,2,9
Financing	Klarna (in the product page code)¹⁰
Payment	Credit cards; PayPal in the checkout code^9,10
Company named on the site	No: only 'Gabriel & Co.'^{1,2,3,5,7,9,12}

How Gabriel & Co. scores

Identity & transparency	15 / 20 New York address in its site markup and on Google; Phone, email and live chat; Domain registered in 2001; Only 'Gabriel & Co.'; no company named; Founders Jack and Dominick Gabriel named on the site
Purchase protection	18 / 25 30 days from delivery; Complimentary return shipping with a prepaid UPS label; Refund to the original payment, no restocking fee; Same 30 days; the returns page speaks of pre-paid postage and suggests insuring the parcel; Only used pieces excluded; Free, with an adult signature; insurance not mentioned; Lost or stolen parcels not addressed
Warranty & aftercare	7 / 15 Lifetime, manufacturing defects (registration needed); Free inspection and cleaning at participating retailers; wear repairs free in the first year only; Sells rings; resizing not mentioned; Warranty terms referred to but not published
Product transparency	9 / 15 Diamonds set in the piece: total weight and average clarity and color stated; engagement settings come without a center stone; Gold karat without alloy; silver as 925; A 'synthetic' sapphire in one page address isn't called synthetic on the page; mother-of-pearl listed as 'Black Pearl'; No appraisal mentioned; Kimberley Process; RJC-certified recycled gold
Payment safety	10 / 10 Cards; PayPal in the checkout code; Klarna; Stripe and Braintree
Reputation	7 / 15 3 out of 5 from 2 reviews: too few; New York location: 4.8 from 360 reviews; No BBB profile found; No recurring complaint pattern

We are still checking Gabriel & Co. on Trustpilot and the BBB; the score will be updated when that's done.

The same rules apply to every store. How the Trust Score works

Who is behind Gabriel & Co.

Gabriel & Co.’s story begins in Lebanon, where Jack and Dominick were born into a family of master jewelers; the family moved to the United States in 1983⁷, and in 1989 the brothers founded their own atelier in New York City⁷. The site names the founders as Jack Gabriel and Dominick Gabriel and calls Jack Gabriel its CEO⁸, and the company’s LinkedIn description says it is family owned and operated¹⁹. It runs its own manufacturing facility³ and sells through authorized retailers, ‘over 800 doors nationwide’, as well as on its own website³; this Trust Check scores orders placed on gabrielny.com.

The site doesn’t name a legal company: its privacy policy speaks only of ‘Gabriel & Co.’^{1,2,3,5,7,9,12}. Its business markup gives an address at 545 W 45th St, 3rd floor, New York, NY 10036¹², the same address its Google and Trustpilot listings show^11,20. The gabrielny.com domain dates from November 2001²¹.

All details we checked

Background	Jack and Dominick, born into a family of jewelers in Lebanon; the family moved to the US in 1983⁷
Founded	1989, as the brothers' own atelier in New York City⁷
Founders	Jack Gabriel and Dominick Gabriel⁸
Chief executive	Jack Gabriel, CEO and founder⁸
Ownership	Family owned and operated (its LinkedIn description)¹⁹
Manufacturing	Its own manufacturing facility³
Retail network	Authorized retailers, 'over 800 doors nationwide'³
Name on the site	'Gabriel & Co.' — no company form (LLC, Inc.)⁹
Legal entity	Not named on the pages we read^{1,2,3,5,7,9,12}
Address (in the site's business markup)	545 W 45th St, 3rd floor, New York, NY 10036¹²
Address (Trustpilot listing)	West 45th Street 545, 10036, New York²⁰
Domain registered	November 15, 2001²¹

How to reach Gabriel & Co.

Customers can call (212) 519-1420, write to [email protected] or use live chat⁵. Customer support works Monday to Friday, 9 am to 6 pm EST, and chat also runs on Saturdays from 10 am to 2 pm⁵. The engagement collection is available by appointment only, and in-store visits are booked with its retail partners^5,6.

All details we checked

Phone (customers)	(212) 519-1420⁵
Email (customers)	[email protected]⁵
Live chat	Weekdays, and Saturdays 10 am – 2 pm⁵
Hours	Mon–Fri 9 am – 6 pm EST⁵
Engagement rings	By appointment only, at its retail partners; settings only, center stone not included⁶
In-store visits	Booked with its retail partners, for custom orders and the bridal collection⁵

Returns & exchanges

Gabriel & Co. accepts returns for a refund within 30 days of delivery, unworn and in saleable condition with all packaging, and refunds go to the original form of payment¹; used pieces aren’t accepted unless defective¹. To return something, you ask customer service for a return number (RA#) by email, chat or phone¹, attach the return label to the box and keep the security tag on¹. Each return is inspected, and processing takes 5–7 business days after it arrives¹. We found no restocking fee^1,2,9. To exchange, you place a new order within 30 days of the original purchase¹.

Its values page promises complimentary return shipping on all online purchases, with a prepaid UPS label², and product pages say ‘Free Shipping and Returns’¹⁰. The returns page itself is less clear: it says merchandise must be shipped with ‘pre-paid postage’ and suggests insuring the package for the full purchase price¹, and that Gabriel & Co. isn’t liable for goods returned by any method other than its collection service¹.

Use its return label
Gabriel & Co. says it doesn’t accept liability for goods returned by any method other than its collection service¹, so ask customer service for the RA# and use the return label you get rather than shipping the piece on your own¹.

All details we checked

Return window	30 days from delivery, for a refund to the original payment; unworn, saleable, with packaging¹
Used pieces	Not accepted unless defective¹
How to return	Ask customer service for a return number (RA#) by email, chat or phone¹
Return label	Its return label and 'collection service'; it isn't liable for returns sent any other way¹
Condition	Original condition, security tag intact, RA# on the parcel¹
Processing	Inspected by quality control; 5–7 business days after it arrives¹
Restocking fee	None mentioned^1,2,9
Exchanges	Through customer service; the new order within 30 days of the original purchase¹
Return shipping (values page)	Complimentary, with a prepaid UPS label, on all online purchases²
Product pages	'Free Shipping and Returns'¹⁰
Postage and insurance (returns page)	'Pre-paid postage'; it suggests insuring the parcel for the full price¹

Shipping & delivery

Standard shipping is free on US orders and takes 3 to 5 business days for ready-to-ship items, or about 2 weeks for out-of-stock and made-to-order pieces¹; every order needs an adult signature on delivery¹. The site ships only to US addresses, not to PO boxes or freight forwarders, and not outside the US and Canada¹; Canadian customers order from gabrielny.ca and pay import duties, customs fees and provincial taxes¹.

We found no mention of insurance on outgoing parcels^1,2,9, or of what happens if a parcel is lost or stolen^1,5,9. An older shipping text on its privacy-policy page still offers free UPS Next Day Air and FedEx International Priority⁹, while the shipping page says it doesn’t ship outside the US and Canada¹.

All details we checked

Shipping	Free standard shipping on US orders; 3–5 business days, about 2 weeks for made-to-order¹
Signature	Adult signature on every order¹
Where it ships	US addresses only; no PO boxes or freight forwarders¹
Canada	Separate site gabrielny.ca; buyer pays duties, customs fees and provincial taxes¹
Shipping insurance	Not mentioned for deliveries^1,2,9
Lost or stolen parcels	Not addressed^1,5,9
Older shipping text (privacy policy page)	Free UPS Next Day Air and FedEx International Priority⁹

Warranty & aftercare

Every piece bought on its website or from a retailer can be enrolled in Gabriel & Co.’s warranty, but only once you register its serial number, within 30 days of purchase³. The warranty is free for life against manufacturing defects, and for the first year it also covers eligible repairs for normal wear and tear or accidental damage³. A registered piece can be serviced at its retailers no matter where it was bought³, and participating retailers inspect and clean it for free every six months³.

Registering ‘confirms’ that you have read and understood the terms and conditions of the warranty³, but we couldn’t find those terms on the site, and none of the pages we read says what the warranty excludes^1,2,3,4,5. Resizing isn’t mentioned anywhere we looked^{1,2,3,4,5,9,13}.

Engagement rings also get Shop Confidently: one exchange within a year of purchase for a ring of equal or higher value, for registered rings and for the setting only, with a one-year protection warranty that covers all damage⁴. Its Trade-Up Program credits up to 75% of the original retail price toward a bridal piece at least twice as expensive, through an authorized retailer²².

Register within 30 days
Gabriel & Co.’s warranty only covers a piece once its serial number is registered, and that has to be done within 30 days of purchase³. Register as soon as the piece arrives.

All details we checked

Registration	Every piece bought online or from a retailer; register the serial number within 30 days³
Warranty	Free lifetime warranty for manufacturing defects; one year for wear and tear or accidental damage; free inspection and cleaning every six months at participating retailers³
Warranty terms	Registration 'confirms' you read terms and conditions that we couldn't find published³
Written exclusions	None found on the pages we read^1,2,3,4,5
Resizing	Not mentioned on the pages we read^{1,2,3,4,5,9,13}
Shop Confidently (engagement rings)	One exchange within a year for a ring of equal or higher value; setting only; registration needed⁴
Trade-Up Program	Up to 75% of the original retail price toward a bridal piece at least twice as expensive, through a retailer²²

What Gabriel & Co. sells & what it costs

Gabriel & Co.’s product sitemaps list 18,325 product URLs²³. In the product pages our sampler read, the median price was $1,785 for necklaces and $1,825 for wedding bands, and the cheapest piece we saw cost $295²³.

Diamond pieces give the total diamond weight and the average clarity and color, for example 0.80 ct, SI or higher, G-H on a pendant, and call the stones ‘Natural Diamond, GIA verified’¹⁶. Gabriel & Co. says every diamond it uses is verified by GIA as natural and that its fine jewelry comes with a Certificate of Authenticity with GIA diamond verification¹⁷, and each design carries a unique serial number¹⁷. We found no individual grading report on the product pages^{6,10,13,14,15,16,17,24,25,26,27,28}, and its warranty page speaks of ‘certified diamonds’ without naming a lab³. Engagement rings are sold as settings, without the center stone⁶; diamond fine-jewelry pieces such as an 18K Yellow Gold Diamond Bangle at $49,000 list a total weight, here 4.75 ct, rather than single stones¹⁰.

Gold is described by karat and color, such as 14k Rose Gold, without the alloy¹³, and silver as 925 sterling silver¹⁵. Created cubic zirconia is named as such²⁷, but two pages we read don’t label their stones consistently. A pair of Mosaic earrings is called ’14K Yellow Gold Bujukan Diamond Blue Sapphire and Blue Topaz Stud Earrings’, with stones described as ‘naturally unique’¹⁴, while the page’s own address calls it ‘alloy yellow gold plated’ with a ‘synthetic blue sapphire’¹⁴; and a cuff listed with a ‘Black Pearl’ gemstone is described as having ‘black mother pearl’¹⁵. Sapphire studs with 1.86 ct sapphires at $10,000 don’t say whether the stones are treated²⁸, and we found no appraisal offered^{1,3,6,10,13,14,15,16,17,24,25,26,27,28}.

Gabriel & Co. says it follows the Kimberley Process for its diamonds, and since 2023 it has used gold certified by the Responsible Jewelry Council, with most bridal and fashion pieces now made from 100% recycled gold².

Check what the stone is
On the Mosaic earrings page, the title and details say 14k yellow gold and blue sapphire¹⁴, but the page address says ‘alloy yellow gold plated’ and ‘synthetic blue sapphire’¹⁴. Before buying a colored-stone piece, ask customer service whether the stone is natural or lab-created and what the metal is.

All details we checked

Catalog	18,325 product URLs in its product sitemaps²³
Prices (our sample of product pages)	Medians: bracelets $787.50, necklaces $1,785, wedding bands $1,825, engagement settings $2,162.50, earrings $2,462.50; lowest $295²³
Diamond details	Total diamond weight, average clarity and color, 'Natural Diamond, GIA verified' (0.80 ct pendant: SI or higher, G-H)¹⁶
GIA verification	Diamonds verified by GIA as natural; a Certificate of Authenticity 'with GIA diamond verification'¹⁷
Serial numbers	A unique serial number on every design, linked to the buyer once registered¹⁷
Grading report	None mentioned on product pages^{6,10,13,14,15,16,17,24,25,26,27,28}
Warranty page	'certified diamonds', lab not named³
Example	18K Yellow Gold Diamond Bangle, $49,000, 4.75 ct total¹⁰
Gold	Karat and color (14k Rose Gold, 18k Yellow Gold); alloy not given¹³
Silver	925 sterling silver¹⁵
Cubic zirconia	Named 'Created Cubic Zirconia'²⁷
Mosaic earrings (page)	'14K Yellow Gold … Blue Sapphire and Blue Topaz'; stones 'naturally unique'¹⁴
Mosaic earrings (page address)	The address calls the piece 'alloy yellow gold plated' with a 'synthetic blue sapphire'¹⁴
Black pearl cuff	Listed as 'Black Pearl'; the description says 'black mother pearl'¹⁵
Sapphire studs	1.86 ct sapphires, $10,000; treatment not mentioned²⁸
Gemstone treatment	Not mentioned on the sapphire page²⁸
Appraisal	Not mentioned^{1,3,6,10,13,14,15,16,17,24,25,26,27,28}
Diamonds	Kimberley Process²
Recycled gold	Since 2023; RJC-certified gold; most bridal and fashion pieces now 100% recycled gold²

Payment & financing

None of the policy pages we read lists payment methods^1,2,5,9; the privacy policy says that to buy you provide your credit card number and expiration date⁹. The checkout code on its pages includes PayPal Express Checkout through Braintree¹⁰, Klarna’s script with a ‘credit promotion’ badge on product pages¹⁰, and Stripe’s payments module on the Magento platform¹⁷.

All details we checked

Payment methods page	None; the pages we read don't list payment methods^1,2,5,9
Cards	Card details are taken at checkout (privacy policy)⁹
PayPal	PayPal Express Checkout through Braintree (page code)¹⁰
Klarna	Klarna's script and a 'credit promotion' badge on product pages (page code)¹⁰
Checkout	Stripe payments module on Magento (page code)¹⁷

What customers say

Gabriel & Co.’s New York location, listed on Google as a jewelry designer at 545 W 45th St, is rated 4.8 from 360 reviews¹¹, and that’s the rating we score. Trustpilot shows 3 out of 5, but from only 2 reviews¹⁸. We found no BBB profile, and we’re still checking Trustpilot and the BBB by hand.

Forum comments are mostly positive: on PriceScope, buyers call its pieces ‘good quality for the price’²⁹, on Weddingbee one owner reports ‘no bending or warping’ about a year after buying from a local jeweler³⁰, and a Reddit poster calls it ‘an amazing vendor’³¹. The criticism we found is scattered: another Reddit user calls the quality ‘pretty mediocre’³², and PriceScope members stopped suggesting one particular setting after complaints²⁹.

All details we checked

Google (New York head office)	4.8 from 360 reviews¹¹
Trustpilot	3 out of 5 from 2 reviews¹⁸
PriceScope forum	'good quality for the price'²⁹
Weddingbee forum	A ring bought from a local jeweler: 'no bending or warping'³⁰
Reddit, r/EngagementRings	'an amazing vendor', with an exchange program³¹
Reddit, r/EngagementRings	'pretty mediocre as far as quality goes'³²
PriceScope forum	Members stopped suggesting one setting after complaints²⁹

Linked from Gabriel & Co.’s own website, so these are the brand’s real accounts.

Alternatives to Gabriel & Co.

Shane Co. — A family-owned US jeweler with free 60-day returns, free insured shipping and a lifetime warranty
Keyzar — Online engagement rings with GIA or IGI reports and a lifetime manufacturing-defect warranty
Grown Brilliance — Lab-grown diamonds with a named company, stores in a dozen cities and a lifetime manufacturing warranty

Gabriel & Co. FAQ

Is Gabriel & Co. legit?

Yes. It’s a New York jewelry designer and manufacturer founded in 1989 by the brothers Jack and Dominick Gabriel^7,8, selling on its own website and through authorized retailers³. Online orders get free shipping with an adult signature, 30 days to return for a refund, and a lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects once registered^1,3. Our score is held back by no legal company named on the site^{1,2,3,5,7,9,12}, unpublished warranty terms^1,2,3,4,5 and stone names that don’t always match their pages^14,15.

Who owns Gabriel & Co.?

Gabriel & Co. describes itself on LinkedIn as family owned and operated¹⁹. It was founded by the brothers Jack Gabriel and Dominick Gabriel, and the site calls Jack Gabriel its CEO and founder⁸. The site doesn’t name the legal entity behind it^{1,2,3,5,7,9,12}.

What is Gabriel & Co.'s return policy?

Online purchases can be returned for a refund to the original payment within 30 days of delivery, unworn and in saleable condition with all packaging; used pieces aren’t accepted unless defective¹. You first ask customer service for a return number (RA#) and use its return label¹; the site promises complimentary return shipping with a prepaid UPS label². Returns are inspected and processed in 5–7 business days¹.

What does the Gabriel & Co. warranty cover?

A free lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects, plus a year’s cover for normal wear and tear or accidental damage, for pieces whose serial number is registered within 30 days of purchase³; participating retailers inspect and clean them for free every six months³. Engagement rings also get Shop Confidently, one exchange within a year for a ring of equal or higher value⁴. The warranty’s full terms aren’t published on the site^1,2,3,4,5.

How do Gabriel & Co. serial numbers and certificates work?

Every design bears a unique serial number that links you to your purchase once it’s registered for the warranty¹⁷, and its fine jewelry comes with a Certificate of Authenticity with GIA verification that the diamonds are natural¹⁷. Product pages give the total diamond weight and the average clarity and color, such as 0.80 ct, SI or higher, G-H¹⁶.

Does Gabriel & Co. ship to Canada?

Not from gabrielny.com, which ships only to US addresses¹; Canadian customers order through gabrielny.ca and pay import duties, customs fees and provincial taxes¹. US standard shipping is free and takes 3 to 5 business days for ready-to-ship items, with an adult signature¹.

Where can I buy Gabriel & Co.?

On its own website or from its authorized retailers, which the site puts at ‘over 800 doors nationwide’³. Its engagement collection is available by appointment only, with in-store visits booked through its retail partners^5,6. Its New York address is 545 W 45th St^11,12.

How we score stores

The Trust Score adds up 100 points across six areas: identity & transparency (20), purchase protection (25), warranty & aftercare (15), product transparency (15), payment safety (10), reputation (15). Every point is tied to a fact we can link to, and the rules are the same for every store. Read the full methodology.

90+ Excellent · 75–89 Trustworthy · 60–74 Mostly reliable · below 60 Proceed with caution. Ratings from other platforms are summarized in our own words with a link; we don’t copy reviews.

Update history

Nov 2, 2026 — First published, before our editor’s review. Every fact checked against gabrielny.com and the other sources listed below as they read that day.

About this review

Researched and written by the Trusted Jewelries team. Every fact is checked against its source by our software. Our editor, Valentina Di Roberto, hasn’t reviewed this Trust Check yet; once that’s done, the editor’s name and the review date will appear here. Stores can’t pay for a review or a score. Found a mistake or a policy that has changed? Tell us and we’ll correct it.

Sources

All pages were read on Nov 2, 2026. Store policies change — check the store’s current terms before you buy.

Gabriel & Co.

66/100 · Mostly reliable

Best for: New York bridal and fine-jewelry designer since 1989, sold online and through retailers

Visit Gabriel & Co.

We may earn a commission. It never changes the score.

Other stores we’ve checked

Shane Co.78/100 · TrustworthyFamily-owned US jeweler since 1929: engagement rings, diamonds, pearls · Visit

Keyzar78/100 · TrustworthyEngagement rings with lab-grown or natural diamonds · Visit

Grown Brilliance76/100 · TrustworthyLab-grown diamond engagement rings and fine jewelry, online or in its stores · Visit

Plum Diamonds73/100 · Mostly reliableLab-grown diamond engagement rings from Chicago, made in its own workshops, with free lifetime care · Visit

Monica Vinader71/100 · Mostly reliableBritish gold-vermeil and recycled-silver jewelry with 100-day returns and a 5-year warranty · Visit

How we check stores →

Gabriel & Co.: Trust Check

Best for

Not ideal for

What we like

Watch out for

Gabriel & Co. policies at a glance

How Gabriel & Co. scores

Who is behind Gabriel & Co.

How to reach Gabriel & Co.

Returns & exchanges

Shipping & delivery

Warranty & aftercare

What Gabriel & Co. sells & what it costs

Payment & financing

What customers say

Official social profiles

Alternatives to Gabriel & Co.

Gabriel & Co. FAQ

How we score stores

Update history

Sources