A Trust Check answers one question: how safe is it to buy from this store? It doesn’t judge whether the jewelry is beautiful or the prices are the lowest. It looks at what happens to your money and your order — who you are buying from, what the return and warranty terms really say, how you pay, and what other buyers report.
What every Trust Check includes
- A verdict, a Trust Score out of 100, and who the store is and isn’t a good fit for.
- The store’s key policies at a glance: returns, refunds, shipping, warranty, resizing and payment.
- The fine print, including exclusions and places where the store’s own pages contradict each other.
- Who is behind the store, how to reach it and what other buyers say about it.
- Answers to the questions people search for about the store, and a numbered list of sources.
How we check a store
- We read the store’s own pages. Policies, FAQ, terms of use, warranty, shipping and contact pages, plus a sample of product pages. We save a copy of every page on the day we read it.
- Every fact comes with a quote. Each statement in a review is backed by a word-for-word quote from a saved page or another named source. Before a review can be published, our software checks that every quote really appears in its source. If a quote can’t be found, the fact can’t be used.
- We compare the fine print. We look at what different pages say about the same thing — for example, when a return window starts — and point out conflicts, because that’s where buyers get caught out.
- We check public records. Such as when the store’s domain was registered and, where available, business registries.
- We look at what other buyers say. Ratings on Google, Trustpilot and the Better Business Bureau, and threads on Reddit and forums. We summarize them in our own words with a link and the date we checked. We don’t copy reviews, and we treat them as signals, not proof.
- We test the store ourselves where we can. We ask customer support the same questions we ask every store, go through checkout up to the payment step, or place a test order and send it back. A review always says which of these we did and when, with screenshots or photos. If a review has no hands-on section, we haven’t run these tests for that store yet.
- An editor reviews it. Our GIA Graduate Gemologist, Valentina Di Roberto, checks the facts, the score and the wording. A review the editor has checked carries the editor’s name and the date; until then it is signed by the Trusted Jewelries team and says that the editor’s review is still to come.
The questions in each review’s FAQ are ones people actually search for. We answer a question only when the store’s pages or other sources answer it; if they don’t, we leave it out instead of guessing.
The Trust Score
Trust Score rates how safely you can buy from a store, not how pretty its jewelry is. Every point comes from a fact we can link to: the store's own policies, public registries, and independent review platforms. We don't accept payment for scores, and affiliate commissions don't change them.
The score adds up 100 points across six areas. Each rule below is applied the same way to every store, and every review shows how many points the store got in each area and why.
| Identity & transparency 20 points | Physical address published: 5; none: 0 Phone, email and live chat (WhatsApp or text messaging count as chat): 4; two of three: 2; one: 1 Domain 5+ years old: 3; 2–5 years: 1; under 2: 0 Legal entity named on the site: 5; only in third-party sources: 2; not found: 0 Owners or leadership named on the site (full name): 3; only in third-party sources: 1; not found, or only a first name: 0 |
|---|---|
| Purchase protection 25 points | Return window 30+ days: 6; 14–29 days: 3; shorter or none: 0 Free return shipping: 5; paid: 0 Full refund, no restocking fee: 3; fee or store credit only: 0. A fee charged only on pieces sent back worn or not in new condition doesn't count: unworn pieces still get a full refund, and a store that refuses worn pieces outright would score no better Return terms consistent across the store's pages: 4; minor wording differences: 2; conflicting deadlines or conditions: 1 Few return exclusions: 2; custom, engraved or resized pieces excluded or refunded only as store credit (common in fine jewelry): 1; most items final sale: 0 Free, insured shipping with signature: 3; insured but either paid or without a signature: 2; uninsured, or insurance not mentioned: 0 Lost-package claims handled by the store without extra paperwork: 2; standard carrier claim: 1; notarized statement, refund at the store's sole discretion, or risk of loss on the buyer once the parcel is shipped: 0 |
| Warranty & aftercare 15 points | Lifetime manufacturing-defect warranty: 5; 1+ year: 3; under 1 year or none: 0 Free maintenance (cleaning, re-plating, prong checks): 3; some: 1; none: 0 Free resizing without a time limit: 3; first resize free / time-limited: 2; paid: 0 Not scored if the store sells no finger rings. Few exclusions: 4; typical exclusions (wear, third-party repairs): 2; whole product categories or lost stones excluded, or a warranty promised with no written terms: 1; no warranty to speak of: 0. A warranty that lapses unless the piece is inspected at set intervals scores at most 2 |
| Product transparency 15 points | Larger diamonds (center stones, solitaires, loose) come with a GIA, IGI or AGS report: 5; a report from another independent lab the store names (for example GSI): 3; only the store's own grading, or 'certified' without naming the lab: 1; no grading: 0. A store whose diamonds are only small accent stones: total carat weight and quality stated: 5; carat weight only: 2; neither: 0. Body piercing jewelry is scored on its metal instead: implant-grade metal with an ASTM standard or mill certificates: 5; grade named without a standard: 2; neither: 0 Not scored if the store sells no diamonds (and no body piercing jewelry). Metal fully described — karat and alloy for solid gold, fineness for silver and platinum (925, 950), base metal plus plating and its thickness for plated pieces: 4; gold karat without alloy, or plating without thickness: 2; vague ('gold tone', 'alloy'): 0 Natural, lab-grown and simulants clearly labeled: 3; partly — including simulants called 'diamond' anywhere on the store's own pages, such as menu sections or articles, lab-grown diamonds sold only as 'cultured' without 'lab-grown' or 'laboratory-created', or a stone sold under the name of a different stone (for example aventurine as 'jade'): 1 Independent appraisal included: 2; store's own appraisal: 1; none: 0 Not scored if the store sells no diamonds or precious gemstones beyond small accent stones. Published sourcing policy (Kimberley Process, recycled metals): 1 |
| Payment safety 10 points | Credit cards and PayPal: 4; only one of the two: 3; wire, crypto or Zelle only: 0 Established installment providers (Affirm, Klarna, Shop Pay…): 3; in-house only: 1; none: 0 (neutral for low prices) Not scored if most products cost under $100. Established checkout provider (Shopify, BigCommerce, Stripe…): 3; unknown: 1 |
| Reputation 15 points | Trustpilot 4.5+ with 500+ reviews: 6; 4.0+ with 100+: 3; lower or too few: 0 Google 4.5+ with 100+ reviews: 4; 4.0+: 2; lower: 0. A chain is rated by its flagship or head-office location; if it names neither, by the tier that every one of its store ratings we found in Google reaches; for an online-only store these 4 points move to Trustpilot (same thresholds) BBB A- or better with complaints answered: 2; a lower grade or unanswered complaints: 1; F, or a BBB alert about a pattern of complaints: 0 No recurring complaint pattern: 3; recurring delays, slow communication or disputed warranty claims: 1; non-delivery or fraud reports: 0 |
We score the terms that apply to an online order delivered to the US. Warranties, repairs and other services that a store offers only for purchases made in its own stores, or only at stores outside the US, don't count for an online order. A store that sells online only within one other country and doesn't ship to the US (for example a Canadian chain) is scored on an online order delivered within that country: services at its stores in that country count, prices are read in its own currency, and the review says so at the top.
Missing information scores zero. If a store doesn't publish what an item needs, the item gets 0 points: we don't guess in the store's favour.
When a store's own pages disagree, we score the terms that are worse for the buyer, because those are the ones the store can hold you to. The conflict itself also costs points under clear return terms. A single line that contradicts a detailed policy on the same page (for example 'All sales are final' at the end of a 30-day return policy) counts as conflicting terms; the other return items are then scored on the detailed policy, and the review points out the line.
A legal cancellation period printed alongside a longer returns policy, such as the 14-day right to cancel under UK or EU law, doesn't replace that policy: we score the return window on the longer policy and count the shorter legal period only as a minor wording difference, unless the two set conflicting conditions.
Some items don't apply to every store: diamond grading if a store sells no diamonds, appraisals if it sells no diamonds or precious gemstones, resizing if it sells no finger rings, and installment plans if most products cost under $100. Those items are left out instead of scored as zero, and the remaining points are scaled to 100 (points earned ÷ points available × 100, rounded). Every review lists the items left out.
The return window is the time you have to send an item back for your money: a longer period that only allows an exchange or store credit is described in the review but doesn't count as the return window. When a store's warranty differs by product line, we score the warranty that covers its main line — what most of its products are — and describe any longer warranty on a single line, such as bridal or custom pieces, without counting it. Likewise, a shorter return window for one category outside the main line (loose diamonds at a ring seller, say) is described and counted against clear return terms, not scored as the window.
Business days are converted at five a week (10 business days = 14 days). A benefit offered only above an order value — free return shipping over $100, say — counts if most of the store's products cost more than that. Original shipping, duties and taxes that aren't refunded don't count as a return fee. A store's own wording counts wherever it appears, including the page descriptions Google shows for its pages. Paid services kept on a return (ring sizing, engraving) aren't a restocking fee either. A store that takes the risk of loss in transit but doesn't say what it does about a lost parcel scores 1 for lost-package claims; an explicit refund or reshipment scores 2.
A warranty that every buyer can extend to lifetime by registering the purchase online, with no fee, counts as a lifetime warranty; the review describes the registration step. Shipping counts as insured only if the store says your parcel is insured: a passing mention of insurance (“for insurance reasons we can't reroute packages”) doesn't. Holiday return dates that have already passed but are still printed on a policy page are a minor wording difference under clear return terms, not conflicting deadlines.
A fixed amount kept from a refund is scored by what the store calls it: return shipping or the return label means return shipping isn't free and the refund is otherwise full; a handling, processing or restocking fee is a fee. An amount the store doesn't name, kept when it sends you a return label, counts as the label's cost. A holiday extension of the return window is described but isn't the window. If sale items are final sale while the store shows a sitewide discount, or most of its products marked down, most items are final sale. A discount or store credit offered for a faulty piece isn't a warranty, and a warranty that covers only another product line (bags, watches) leaves the jewelry without one. 'Most products cost under $100' means more than half of the products in the store's product feed, at their lowest price.
A TrustScore quoted in Google's snippet of the store's Trustpilot page counts; without one, the star rating Google shows under that page does, and if the two differ the lower counts. When the number of reviews isn't known, the Trustpilot item scores 0, but the Google tier that needs no review count still applies when an online-only store's Google points move to Trustpilot. A Google listing at an address the store itself gives (shop, showroom or head office) is rated like a store; a store whose only shops are outside the US counts as online-only for a US buyer.
A PO box or a private mailbox (PMB) at a mail-receiving service isn't a physical address on its own: the address item needs a street address where the business is. The order-value rule above also applies to shipping insurance and signatures: insurance or a signature offered only above an order value counts only if most of the store's products cost more than that.
What the score means: 90–100 Excellent, 75–89 Trustworthy, 60–74 Mostly reliable, below 60 Proceed with caution.
If part of a check is still pending — for example, a store’s BBB profile — the review says so, and the score is updated when the check is done.
The dates on every review
- Published — when the review first went live.
- Updated — the last time we changed what the review says.
- Facts checked — the day we last read the store’s pages and checked every fact against them.
Every review ends with an update history. Store policies change, so always confirm the current terms on the store’s own site before you buy.
How often we re-check
We aim to re-check every store at least every six months, and sooner when we learn that a policy has changed. When we do, we update the “Facts checked” date and add a line to the review’s update history.
How we make money
Trusted Jewelries is free to read. Some links to stores are affiliate links: if you click one and buy something, the store or an affiliate network may pay us a commission. It costs you nothing extra.
- Stores can’t pay for a review, a score or a better position.
- Commissions don’t change the score. It is calculated only from the rules on this page.
- We say so next to every “Visit store” button.
How we use software and AI
We use software to save store pages, pull out quotes and check that every quote matches its source, and we use AI tools to help extract facts and draft the text. AI is not a source: a statement can only appear in a review if it is backed by a quote from a saved page or another named source, and an editor reviews the facts, the score and the wording — reviews published before that check are signed by the Trusted Jewelries team and say so.
Corrections
Spotted a mistake, or a store policy that has changed? Tell us through our contact page. We check the report against the store’s current pages, fix factual errors and note the change in the review’s update history. Stores are welcome to send corrections too: we fix facts, but we don’t change a score on request — only when the facts behind it change.
Changes to this methodology
- Nov 3, 2026 — version 1.11: Clarified: a PO box or private mailbox alone isn't a physical address; the order-value rule also applies to shipping insurance and signatures, so two published reviews were re-scored (Mignon Faget, Shane Co.).
- Nov 3, 2026 — version 1.10: Clarified recurring cases: a fixed amount kept from a refund is scored by what the store calls it; a holiday extension isn't the return window; sale items final sale during a sitewide sale means most items are final sale; a discount for a faulty piece, or a warranty on another product line only, isn't a jewelry warranty; 'most products under $100' is read off the product feed; without a quoted TrustScore, the star rating Google shows for a store's Trustpilot page counts; a Google listing at the address the store gives is rated like a store.
- Nov 3, 2026 — version 1.9: Clarified recurring cases: a warranty that every buyer can extend to lifetime by registering the purchase online counts as a lifetime warranty; a passing mention of insurance that doesn't say your parcel is insured counts as insurance not mentioned; expired holiday dates left on a policy page are a minor wording difference, not conflicting deadlines.
- Nov 2, 2026 — version 1.8: Clarified recurring cases: the return window is the time to return for a refund (a longer exchange- or credit-only period doesn't count); when warranties differ by product line, the one covering the store's main line is scored; business days convert at five a week; a benefit offered above an order value counts if most products cost more; unrefunded shipping, duties and taxes aren't a return fee; the store's own wording counts wherever it appears, including its page descriptions in Google.
- Nov 2, 2026 — version 1.7: Diamond grading: a report from another independent lab that the store names (for example GSI) now scores 3 of 5, between a GIA, IGI or AGS report (5) and diamonds sold as 'certified' without naming the lab (1, as before).
- Nov 2, 2026 — version 1.6: A chain that names neither a flagship nor a head-office store gets the Google tier that every store rating we found for it reaches, so a single well-rated store can't lift the score.
- Nov 2, 2026 — version 1.5: A store that sells online only within one other country and doesn't ship to the US, such as a Canadian chain, is scored on an online order delivered within that country, and its review says so at the top.
- Oct 31, 2026 — version 1.4: A stone sold under the name of a different stone (for example aventurine called 'jade' in a product's name or description) counts as partly labeled, like a simulant called 'diamond'.
- Oct 30, 2026 — version 1.3: A fee charged only on pieces returned worn or not in new condition doesn't count as a restocking fee: the full-refund item is scored on what you get back for an unworn piece.
- Oct 29, 2026 — version 1.2: A legal cancellation period (such as the 14-day right under UK or EU law) printed alongside a longer returns policy doesn't replace it: the return window is scored on the longer policy.
- Oct 29, 2026 — version 1.1: We score the terms for an online order delivered to the US. Items that don't apply to a store (diamond grading, appraisals, resizing, installments) are left out and the score is scaled to 100; missing information scores zero; when a store's pages disagree we score the less favorable terms (a single stray line that contradicts a detailed policy is treated as a conflict, not as the policy). Clarified rules for plated metal, body-jewelry metal, accent diamonds, store-credit refunds, insured shipping without a signature, chains (Google rating of the flagship), BBB grades between A- and F, simulants called 'diamond' in menus or articles and lab-grown diamonds sold only as 'cultured' (partly labeled), WhatsApp or text messaging as chat, warranties promised without written terms, and owners named by first name only (not counted).
- Oct 28, 2026 — version 1.0: First public version.