Our verdict
A real Florida body-jewelry seller, well rated on Google — but you can only return unopened items within 14 days, there's no warranty, and nothing is said about material certificates.
Visit BodyJewelry.comBest for
The bottom line. BodyJewelry.com is run by AGB Body Jewelry Inc. in Margate, Florida6, founded by Avi Gidon7, on a domain registered in 19998. It sells G23 implant-grade titanium, 316L steel and 14k or 18k gold piercing jewelry2,3, mostly around $18–$281, ships free over $29.999 and gives a free return label5. Google shows 4.9 stars from 301 reviews10. It scores lower on protection and aftercare: returns are limited to unopened items within 14 days5, insurance costs extra9, there’s no warranty3,5,7,9, and it names no material standard or mill certificates for its titanium2,3,4.
What we like
Watch out for
On this page
At a glanceTrust Score breakdownWho is behind BodyJewelry.comHow to reach BodyJewelry.comReturns, refunds & cancellationsShipping & deliveryWarrantyWhat BodyJewelry.com sells & what it costsPaymentWhat customers sayBodyJewelry.com dealsBodyJewelry.com FAQUpdate historySourcesOther stores we’ve checked
BodyJewelry.com policies at a glance
| Return window | 14 days from delivery, unopened items only5 |
|---|---|
| Return shipping | Free prepaid label5 |
| Can't be returned | Anything opened or worn (hygiene)5 |
| Refund | Refund, credit or exchange, your choice; 1–2 weeks5 |
| Warranty | None described3,5,7,9 |
| Shipping | Free over $29.99 (3–7 days); insurance $5.98 option9 |
| Handling time | 2–3 business days; 14k gold 4–69 |
| Company named on the site | Yes: AGB Body Jewelry Inc., Margate, FL6 |
How BodyJewelry.com scores
| Identity & transparency | 20 / 20 Margate, FL address in the Terms; Phone, email and live chat; Domain registered in 1999; AGB Body Jewelry Inc. named; Founder and CEO named |
| Purchase protection | 19 / 25 14 days; Free prepaid label; Product price refunded; no restocking fee; Return page and FAQ agree; Anything opened or worn excluded; Insurance only as a paid option; Buyer is sent to USPS |
| Warranty & aftercare | 0 / 12 No warranty; No aftercare; Sells no finger rings (doesn't apply); No warranty to speak of |
| Product transparency | 9 / 13 Titanium grade named, no ASTM standard or mill certificates; Grade stated: G23 titanium, 316L steel, 14k gold; Cubic zirconia named as such; No diamonds or precious gemstones (doesn't apply); No sourcing policy |
| Payment safety | 7 / 7 Cards via Stripe, and PayPal; Most items cost under $100 (doesn't apply); BigCommerce checkout, Stripe |
| Reputation | 7 / 15 No Trustpilot profile found; 4.9 from 301 reviews; No BBB profile found; No recurring complaint pattern found |
Not scored because they don't apply to BodyJewelry.com: resizing, appraisal, installments. The other 92 points are scaled to 100 (62 of 92). We are still looking for BodyJewelry.com's Trustpilot and BBB profiles; the score will be updated when that's done.
The same rules apply to every store. How the Trust Score works
Who is behind BodyJewelry.com
The site is operated by AGB Body Jewelry Inc., 1755 Banks Road, Margate, Florida6, and its founder and CEO is Avi Gidon7. The domain was registered in March 19998; the About page claims more than ten years in business7. Product pages also carry the name ‘Luxe Modz’2. Oddly, the About page’s ‘Address’ heading is empty7 — the address is in the Terms. Disputes go to binding arbitration in Broward County under Florida law6.
All details we checked
| Legal entity | AGB Body Jewelry Inc., 1755 Banks Road, Margate, FL 330636 |
|---|---|
| Founder & CEO | Avi Gidon7 |
| Domain registered | March 5, 19998 |
| Years in business (claimed) | '10+'; 'over a decade'7 |
| Also sold as | 'Luxe Modz' (in page titles)2 |
| Address on the About page | The 'Address' heading is empty7 |
| Disputes | Florida law; binding arbitration in Broward County6 |
How to reach BodyJewelry.com
You can call or text a toll-free or Florida number, email support, or use live chat, Monday to Friday 9 AM–6 PM Eastern5,11; emails are answered in one to two business days9.
All details we checked
| Phone | 1-888-242-6166 (toll-free), 954-933-2259; call or text11 |
|---|---|
| [email protected], answered in 1–2 business days9 | |
| Live chat | During business hours5 |
| Hours | Mon–Fri 9 AM–6 PM Eastern11 |
Returns, refunds & cancellations
You have 14 days from delivery to start a return, and only for items that haven’t been opened or worn and are still in their original packaging — a hygiene rule common for piercing jewelry5. The store emails a free prepaid return label5, and you choose a refund, store credit or exchange; the original shipping and any ‘warranty fees’ aren’t refunded3,5. Processing takes about one to two weeks5. If you got the wrong item, the right one is sent right away5.
You can cancel an order before it ships from your account, or ask for a change within two hours of ordering3.
All details we checked
| Return window | 14 days from delivery (postmark)5 |
|---|---|
| Condition | Unopened and unworn, in original packaging (hygiene)5 |
| Return shipping | Free prepaid label by email5 |
| Refund options | Refund, store credit or exchange — your choice; shipping and 'warranty fees' not refunded5 |
| Shipping on returns | Original shipping cost isn't refunded3 |
| Processing | About 1–2 weeks after it arrives5 |
| Wrong item | Correct item sent right away5 |
| Cancellation | Before shipping, from your account or by contacting them within 2 hours3 |
Shipping & delivery
Orders leave in two to three business days, 14k gold in four to six9. Shipping is free over $29.99 and takes three to seven days9; insurance is a paid option at $5.989, and Priority or Express cost $18.75 and $49.759. If tracking says delivered but nothing arrived, the FAQ sends you to USPS, and the store says it isn’t liable for misdelivered or stolen parcels3. It ships to APO/FPO addresses and abroad9.
All details we checked
| Handling time | 2–3 business days; 14k gold 4–69 |
|---|---|
| Free shipping | Over $29.99, 3–7 days9 |
| Insurance | Optional: Economy + Insurance $5.989 |
| Faster options | Priority $18.75 (2–3 days), Express $49.75 (1–2 days)9 |
| 'Delivered' but missing | Contact USPS; the store isn't liable for misdelivered or stolen parcels3 |
| APO/FPO | Shipped via USPS9 |
| International | Mail Ground $12.75 (5–8 days), UPS Express $59.959 |
Warranty
None of the store’s policy pages describes a warranty3,5,7,9; the only mention is that ‘warranty fees’ aren’t refunded on returns5.
All details we checked
| Warranty | None described on the return, shipping, FAQ or About pages3,5,7,9 |
|---|---|
| 'Warranty fees' | Mentioned only as non-refundable on returns5 |
What BodyJewelry.com sells & what it costs
The store lists 14k and 18k gold, G23 implant-grade titanium, 316L surgical steel and acrylic3, and says it prioritizes nickel-free materials1. The titanium belly ring we checked listed its grade, gauge, length and cubic zirconia stones clearly2. What we didn’t find is an ASTM standard (such as F136) or mill certificates for the titanium2,3,4 — many piercers look for those for fresh piercings.
Prices in the home page’s code are mostly around $18–$281, across what Google describes as over 5,000 styles1. There’s no sourcing policy3,6,7.
All details we checked
| Materials | 14k and 18k gold, G23 implant-grade titanium, 316L surgical steel, acrylic3 |
|---|---|
| Belly ring we checked | G23 implant-grade titanium, 14 gauge, CZ stones, PVD colors2 |
| Nickel | Says it prioritizes nickel-free materials1 |
| Material certificates | No mill certificates or ASTM standard named2,3,4 |
| Prices in the home page code | Mostly about $18–$281 |
| Range | 'Over 5000' styles1 |
| Sourcing policy | None found3,6,7 |
Payment
Checkout runs on BigCommerce, and the Privacy Policy names Stripe and PayPal as payment processors1,12. Your card’s billing address must match3.
All details we checked
| Checkout platform | BigCommerce (page code)1 |
|---|---|
| Payment processors | Stripe and PayPal (named in the Privacy Policy)12 |
| Cards | Card billing address must match3 |
What customers say
Its Google profile in Margate, Florida shows 4.9 stars from 301 reviews10, and the site counts 5,456 verified reviews of its own7. We found no Trustpilot profile for bodyjewelry.com in Google’s results13, and no BBB profile. On Reddit’s piercing forum, where many users prefer specialist brands, one commenter said in 2020 that the store doesn’t sell decent-quality jewelry14.
All details we checked
| Google (Margate, FL) | 4.9 stars, 301 reviews10 |
|---|---|
| Reviews on its own site | '5456 verified reviews'7 |
| Trustpilot | No profile for bodyjewelry.com found in Google results13 |
| Reddit: 'Is jewelry from bodyjewelry.com reliable' (r/piercing, 2020) | One commenter says it doesn't sell decent-quality jewelry14 |
BodyJewelry.com deals
On October 29, 2026 product pages advertised buy two, get one free, excluding 14k gold2, on top of free shipping over $29.999.
All details we checked
| Running offer | Buy 2, get 1 free (not on 14k gold)2 |
|---|
Official social profiles
Linked from BodyJewelry.com’s own website, so these are the brand’s real accounts.
Alternatives to BodyJewelry.com
- Studs — Piercing studio chain that also sells jewelry online
- Body Candy — A large online body-jewelry store often compared with it
BodyJewelry.com FAQ
Is BodyJewelry.com legit?
Yes. It’s operated by a named Florida company, AGB Body Jewelry Inc. in Margate6, its domain dates from 19998, and its Google profile shows 4.9 stars from 301 reviews10. Keep in mind that only unopened items can be returned, within 14 days5, and there’s no warranty3,5,7,9.
Where is BodyJewelry.com located?
In Margate, Florida: AGB Body Jewelry Inc., 1755 Banks Road6. Orders ship from Florida2.
What is BodyJewelry.com's return policy?
Start a return within 14 days of delivery, for unopened, unworn items in their original packaging5. The store emails a free return label5, and you pick a refund, store credit or exchange; shipping and ‘warranty fees’ aren’t refunded5.
Is BodyJewelry.com titanium implant grade?
The titanium pieces are sold as G23 implant-grade titanium2,3, but the pages we read name no ASTM standard and offer no mill certificates2,3,4. Ask the store for certificates if you need them for a new piercing.
How we score stores
The Trust Score adds up 100 points across six areas: identity & transparency (20), purchase protection (25), warranty & aftercare (15), product transparency (15), payment safety (10), reputation (15). Every point is tied to a fact we can link to, and the rules are the same for every store. Read the full methodology.
90+ Excellent · 75–89 Trustworthy · 60–74 Mostly reliable · below 60 Proceed with caution. Ratings from other platforms are summarized in our own words with a link; we don’t copy reviews.
Update history
- Oct 29, 2026 — First published, before our editor’s review. Every fact checked against BodyJewelry.com's pages as they read that day.
Researched and written by the Trusted Jewelries team. Every fact is checked against its source by our software. Our editor, Valentina Di Roberto, hasn’t reviewed this Trust Check yet; once that’s done, the editor’s name and the review date will appear here. Stores can’t pay for a review or a score. Found a mistake or a policy that has changed? Tell us and we’ll correct it.
Sources
All pages were read on Oct 29, 2026. Store policies change — check the store’s current terms before you buy.
- BodyJewelry.com — home page
- BodyJewelry.com — product page: Titanium CNC Set CZ Hinged Belly Button Ring Piercings 14G | Luxe Modz
- BodyJewelry.com — Frequently Asked Questions | BodyJewelry.com
- BodyJewelry.com — Titanium Body Jewelry & Implant Grade Titanium | BodyJewelry.com
- BodyJewelry.com — Returns & Exchanges | Free Returns | BodyJewelry.com
- BodyJewelry.com — Terms and Conditions | Body Piercing Jewellery
- BodyJewelry.com — About Us – Body Piercings Jewelry
- Domain registration record (RDAP)
- BodyJewelry.com — Shipping Information | Get Fast Delivered Body Jewelry
- Google Business Profile: BodyJewelry.com | Luxe Modz, Margate, FL (as shown in Google search)
- BodyJewelry.com — Contact Us
- BodyJewelry.com — Privacy Policy | Collects & Protects Customer Information
- trustpilot.com: Body Jewelry Factory Reviews — Google result snippet, Oct 29, 2026
- reddit.com: Is jewelry from “bodyjewelry.com” reliable and also what … — Google result snippet, Oct 29, 2026