Yes, it's a real company: BaubleBar Inc., based in New York City, on a domain registered in 2010. Its returns are easy — 30 days from shipping with a prepaid label — but it offers no warranty beyond a 3-day check on arrival, and Google shows it at 4 stars from 648 reviews on Trustpilot.

The site is run by BaubleBar Inc.. Its LinkedIn page names Amy Jain and Daniella Yacobovsky as the founders, and press profiles call Amy Jain co-founder and CEO; the pages we read on the site name neither.

BaubleBar Review: Is BaubleBar Legit? Trust Check (November 2026)

Q: Does BaubleBar have a warranty?

We found none. Its quality guarantee covers only pieces that arrive 'less than perfect': send a photo to HelpMe@BaubleBar.com within 3 business days.

Q: How do I contact BaubleBar?

Email HelpMe@BaubleBar.com — agents work from 9am to 9pm EST — or use the contact form; it aims to respond within 24 hours. There's no phone line.

Q: How long does BaubleBar take to ship?

Most in-stock items ship within 24–48 hours; Standard delivery then takes 5–7 business days, Expedited 3–5 and Rush 2–3. Custom pieces are made to order, with an expected ship date on the product page.

By the Trusted Jewelries team · Published Nov 3, 2026 · Updated Nov 3, 2026 · Facts checked Nov 3, 2026 · How we check stores

59Trust Score

Proceed with caution

See the breakdown

Our verdict

A New York fashion-jewelry brand, BaubleBar Inc., selling plated jewelry, custom pieces and accessories at up to $198, with 30 days to return and a prepaid return label — but no warranty beyond a 3-day check on arrival, no phone line, and gold-plated pieces named '14K Gold'.

Visit BaubleBar

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes the score. How we make money

Best for

Gift and trend shoppers who want inexpensive plated or personalized pieces and an easy 30-day return^1,2

Not ideal for

Anyone who wants a warranty or repairs after the first few days^2,3,4,5,6
Buyers looking for solid gold: the ’14K Gold’ pieces we checked are gold-plated sterling silver^7,8

The bottom line. BaubleBar Inc.⁹ is based in New York City and ships orders from its facility in New Jersey³; its domain dates from 2010¹⁰. It sells fashion jewelry — bracelets, necklaces, earrings and rings — alongside totes, phone cases, blankets and ornaments¹, and the priciest items in its product feed cost $198¹. Returns are simple: 30 days from the shipping date for a full refund to your original payment, with a prepaid label², though custom and made-to-order pieces are final sale². Checkout runs on Shopify with cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Shop Pay^3,11. It loses points because it offers no warranty — only a ‘quality guarantee’ for pieces that arrive less than perfect, reported with a photo within 3 business days^2,3,4,5,6; shipping insurance isn’t mentioned^2,3,4,5,11; the FAQ data in the code of its Shipping & Returns page contradicts its returns policy on the invoice and on sale items⁴; its gold pieces are plated, with no thickness given, yet named ’14K Gold’^{7,8,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19}; and there’s no phone line³. Google shows it at 4 stars from 648 reviews on Trustpilot²⁰.

What we like

30 days from the shipping date to return an item for a full refund to the original payment method²
A prepaid return label from its Returns Portal; its own page descriptions promise ‘free returns’^2,21
A named company, BaubleBar Inc., with a New York address in its terms⁹
Free standard shipping on US orders of $75 or more; most in-stock items ship within 24–48 hours⁴
Product pages list materials, and cubic zirconia and moissanite are named as such^1,7,8
Says every product is certified nickel-free, lead-free and cadmium-free³
Cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Shop Pay on a Shopify checkout^3,11

Watch out for

No warranty: only a ‘quality guarantee’ for pieces that arrive less than perfect, reported within 3 business days^2,3,4,5,6
No repairs or resizing, although it sells rings^1,2,3,4,5,6
Gold pieces are plated, with no plating thickness, but named ’14K Gold’; the home page invites you to shop ’14k and 18k gold’ pieces ‘that will last you a lifetime’^{7,8,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19}
The FAQ data on its Shipping & Returns page contradicts the returns policy: an invoice is required, and sale items can’t be returned, even as gifts^2,4
Custom and made-to-order pieces are final sale and can’t be cancelled^2,3
Shipping insurance isn’t mentioned^2,3,4,5,11
No phone line: email, a contact form and chat only^3,11
Reviews report a bracelet losing stones and earrings leaving green marks; the BBB lists 37 complaints in the last 12 months^22,23,24

How we checked BaubleBar. On Nov 3, 2026 we read 22 pages of BaubleBar’s website — policies, FAQ, terms, warranty and contact pages, and saved a copy of each. All 79 facts in this review come from those copies or from the other sources listed at the end, and each one was checked against its saved source before publishing. We also looked at the domain registration record, Trustpilot, BBB and Reddit.

On this page

At a glance Trust Score breakdown Who is behind BaubleBar How to reach BaubleBar Returns & exchanges Shipping & delivery Warranty & care What BaubleBar sells & what it costs Payment What customers say BaubleBar FAQ Update history Sources

Other stores we’ve checked

Monica Vinader71/100 · Mostly reliableBritish gold-vermeil and recycled-silver jewelry with 100-day returns and a 5-year warranty · Visit

TOUS60/100 · Mostly reliableSpanish jeweler since 1920: silver, vermeil and 18k gold, the teddy-bear brand · Visit

Estella Bartlett57/100 · Proceed with cautionGold- and silver-plated brass jewelry and gifts from a London brand, shipping to the US · Visit

Keyzar78/100 · TrustworthyEngagement rings with lab-grown or natural diamonds · Visit

Shane Co.78/100 · TrustworthyFamily-owned US jeweler since 1929: engagement rings, diamonds, pearls · Visit

BaubleBar policies at a glance

Return window	30 days from the shipping date; orders from November 1 to December 16, 2026 until January 15, 2027^2,4
Return shipping	Prepaid label from its Returns Portal; described as 'free returns'^2,21
Can't be returned	Custom, made-to-order and final-sale items^2,3
Refund	Full refund to the original payment, store credit or an exchange; original shipping not refunded; processed within 5 business days of arrival²
Warranty	None; report a piece that arrives less than perfect within 3 business days^2,3,4,5,6
Resizing	Not offered^2,3,4,5,6
Shipping	Free on US orders of $75 or more ($8 below); insurance not mentioned; US only^2,3,4,5,11
Financing	No installment plan listed; nothing in its feed costs more than $198^1,3
Payment	Cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay (Shopify checkout)^3,11
Company named on the site	Yes: BaubleBar Inc., 1115 Broadway, New York⁹

How BaubleBar scores

Identity & transparency	16 / 20 New York head-office address in its terms; Email and chat; no phone line; Domain registered in 2010; BaubleBar Inc. named in its terms; Founders and CEO named only in third-party sources
Purchase protection	18 / 25 30 days; Prepaid label; 'free returns' in its own descriptions; Full refund to the original payment; only original shipping is kept; Its FAQ data contradicts the policy on the invoice and on sale items; Custom and made-to-order pieces are final sale; Free over $75; insurance not mentioned; You file a claim with the store; Customer Care resolves it
Warranty & aftercare	0 / 15 No warranty; only a 3-day check on arrival; No cleaning, re-plating or repair service; Sells rings; no resizing; No warranty to speak of
Product transparency	5 / 8 Sells no diamonds: cubic zirconia, crystals and moissanite (doesn't apply); Base metal and plating named, no thickness; some pages name no metal; Cubic zirconia and moissanite named as such; No diamonds or precious gemstones (doesn't apply); No sourcing policy found
Payment safety	7 / 7 Cards and PayPal; Most products cost under $100; the priciest are $198 (doesn't apply); Shopify
Reputation	7 / 15 4 stars, 648 reviews; No stores of its own: scored on Trustpilot, 4 stars; Accredited; grade and complaint answers not yet checked; Recurring quality and delivery complaints

Not scored because they don't apply to BaubleBar: diamond grading, appraisal, installments. The other 90 points are scaled to 100 (53 of 90). We are still checking BaubleBar's exact Trustpilot score and its BBB grade; the score will be updated when that's done.

The same rules apply to every store. How the Trust Score works

Who is behind BaubleBar

BaubleBar’s terms name the company behind the site, BaubleBar Inc.⁹, and give its address as 1115 Broadway, 5th Floor, New York, NY 10010⁹. The site says it’s based in New York City and ships every order from its facility in New Jersey³; its markup gives 2010 as the founding year¹¹, and the baublebar.com domain was registered in August 2010¹⁰. The pages we read don’t name its founders or managers^{3,6,9,11,25,26}. Its LinkedIn page names Amy Jain and Daniella Yacobovsky as the founders²⁷, and profiles in the press call Amy Jain co-founder and CEO and Daniella Yacobovsky co-founder and President²⁸.

BaubleBar has no shops of its own; it sells through other retailers, including its shop-in-shop at FAO Schwarz in New York City³, and its separate SugarFix by BaubleBar line is sold at Target³.

All details we checked

Company named on the site	BaubleBar Inc.⁹
Address (terms of service, copyright agent)	1115 Broadway, 5th Floor, New York, NY 10010⁹
Where it's based	New York City; orders ship from its facility in New Jersey³
Founded (site markup)	2010¹¹
Domain registered	August 20, 2010¹⁰
Owners or leadership on the site	Not named on the pages we read^{3,6,9,11,25,26}
Founders (LinkedIn company page)	Amy Jain and Daniella Yacobovsky²⁷
Leadership (press and profiles)	Amy Jain, co-founder and CEO; Daniella Yacobovsky, co-founder and President²⁸
Own shops	None; a shop-in-shop at FAO Schwarz in New York City³
Other line	SugarFix by BaubleBar, sold at Target³

How to reach BaubleBar

BaubleBar has no phone line³. Its Customer Care team answers email at [email protected], with agents available between 9am and 9pm EST³, seven days a week, and aims to respond within 24 hours⁶. There’s also a contact form with topics from orders and custom orders to shipping and returns⁶, and the site loads a Kustomer chat widget¹¹. Once an order is placed, changes and cancellations aren’t guaranteed³, and custom orders can’t be changed or cancelled at all³.

All details we checked

Email	[email protected]; agents 9am–9pm EST³
Hours and reply time	7 days a week, 9am–9pm EST; aims to answer within 24 hours⁶
Contact form	On the contact page, with topics such as orders, custom orders, shipping and returns⁶
Chat (page code)	A Kustomer chat widget is loaded on the site¹¹
Phone	None: 'We do not have a phone line.'³

Returns & exchanges

Eligible items can be returned within 30 days of the shipping date for a full refund to your original form of payment² — unused, with tags attached, in the original packaging, and gift sets in full². You start the return in its Returns Portal, choose a refund, store credit or an exchange, and receive a prepaid return label²; BaubleBar’s own page descriptions call this ‘free returns’^4,21. Exchanges are only for the same item in another size or color². Original shipping fees aren’t refunded², and returns are processed within 5 business days of arriving². Eligible items bought between November 1 and December 16, 2026 can be returned until January 15, 2027⁴.

Custom, made-to-order and final-sale items can’t be returned^2,3. A damaged or wrong order has to be reported within 3 days of delivery², and BaubleBar doesn’t offer price adjustments or apply promotion codes to past orders³.

Two versions of the returns rules
BaubleBar’s returns policy says you don’t need your original invoice² and excludes only custom and final-sale items². The FAQ data embedded in the code of its Shipping & Returns page says otherwise: include your invoice, or the return can’t be processed⁴; custom and sale items can’t be returned, even as gifts⁴; and the 30 days run from purchase, not from shipping⁴. We count this against clear return terms. Keep your order confirmation, and check whether a sale item can be returned before you buy it as a gift.

All details we checked

Return window	30 days from the shipping date, for a full refund to the original payment method²
Return window (FAQ data on the Shipping & Returns page)	30 days 'of purchase'⁴
Condition	Unused, with tags, in the original packaging; gift sets returned in full²
Return label	Prepaid label from the Returns Portal²
'Free returns' (its page description in Google)	'Enjoy free UPS shipping over $75 & free returns.'²¹
'Free returns' (Shipping & Returns page description)	'BaubleBar offers free returns and standard shipping on all U.S. orders of $75 or more.'⁴
Refund, credit or exchange	You choose a refund, store credit or an exchange in the Returns Portal²
Exchanges	Same item in another size or color only; otherwise store credit²
Original shipping	Not refunded²
Processing	Up to 5 business days after it arrives²
Holiday returns	Bought November 1 – December 16, 2026: returnable until January 15, 2027⁴
Not returnable	Custom, made-to-order and final-sale items²
Custom orders	Can't be changed or cancelled; all custom items are final sale³
Invoice (returns policy)	Not needed²
Invoice (FAQ data on the Shipping & Returns page)	Required, or the return can't be processed⁴
Gift returns (FAQ data on the Shipping & Returns page)	Custom and sale items can't be returned⁴
Packing (FAQ data on the Shipping & Returns page)	Returns damaged in transit by poor packing aren't refunded⁴
Damaged or wrong item	Report within 3 days of delivery²
Price adjustments	None³
Cancelling an order	Not guaranteed once placed; custom orders can't be cancelled³

Shipping & delivery

Standard shipping is free on US orders of $75 or more, after discounts and before taxes; smaller orders pay $8⁴. Standard delivery takes 5–7 business days by USPS, Expedited 3–5 business days for $12, and Rush 2–3 business days by FedEx for $20⁴. Most in-stock items ship within 24–48 hours⁴; custom pieces are made to order, with an expected ship date on the product page and at checkout⁵. Everything ships from New Jersey³, and the FAQ data on its Shipping & Returns page says it doesn’t ship outside the United States⁴.

We found no mention of shipping insurance or a signature^2,3,4,5,11. If a parcel shows as delivered but isn’t there, BaubleBar asks you to allow up to 3 more business days⁴; after that, you file a claim and its Customer Care team ‘will get back to you with a solution’⁴.

All details we checked

Free shipping	US orders of $75 or more; $8 below that⁴
Options	Standard 5–7 business days (USPS); Expedited 3–5 ($12); Rush 2–3 by FedEx ($20)⁴
Dispatch	Most in-stock items within 24–48 hours; custom items by the date shown on the product page⁴
Custom items	Made to order; an expected ship date is shown on the product page and at checkout⁵
Outside the US (FAQ data on the Shipping & Returns page)	Not shipped⁴
Insurance or signature	Not mentioned^2,3,4,5,11
Marked delivered but not arrived	Wait up to 3 more business days⁴
Lost parcel	File a claim through its order-help page; Customer Care 'will get back to you with a solution'⁴

Warranty & care

We found no warranty, repair, re-plating or resizing service on BaubleBar’s policy and help pages^2,3,4,5,6. What it calls its quality guarantee covers pieces that are ‘less than perfect upon arrival’: send a photo to [email protected] within 3 business days, and Customer Care will get back to you with a solution³. Its care advice is to clean pieces gently with water, pat them dry and avoid harsh chemicals¹⁴.

All details we checked

Quality guarantee	A piece 'less than perfect upon arrival': send a photo within 3 business days³
Warranty, repairs, resizing	None found on its policy and help pages^2,3,4,5,6
Care advice (product page)	Clean gently with water, pat dry, avoid harsh chemicals¹⁴

What BaubleBar sells & what it costs

BaubleBar calls itself ‘the home of statement and everyday fashion jewelry’¹¹. Its product feed is mostly bracelets, necklaces, earrings and rings, plus totes, bag charms, phone cases, blankets, ornaments and craft kits¹. The priciest items in the feed cost $198, such as the Tana 14K Gold Ring Set¹, and a kids’ bracelet costs $10¹.

Product pages list materials. The gold pieces we checked are ’14K Gold plated sterling silver’⁸, gold-plated brass (a custom bracelet) or gold-plated zinc (a kids’ headband)^14,15, with no plating thickness given^{7,8,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19} — yet the plated pieces are named ’14K Gold’, as in the Vivian 14K Gold Crystal Earring Set⁷, and the home page invites you to ‘Shop 14k and 18k gold’ pieces ‘that will last you a lifetime’¹¹. The Joy Pop cocktail ring lists only enamel and cubic zirconia, with no metal named¹³.

Stones are named plainly: cubic zirconia⁷, and moissanite as an option on some demi-fine earrings¹; we found no diamonds in its feed¹. BaubleBar says every product is hypoallergenic and certified nickel-free, lead-free and cadmium-free³. We found no sourcing policy^3,9,11,25,26.

All details we checked

How it describes itself	'Statement and everyday fashion jewelry', with custom phone cases, blankets and jewelry¹¹
What it sells (product feed)	Mostly fashion jewelry — bracelets, necklaces, earrings, rings — plus totes, bag charms, phone cases, blankets, ornaments and craft kits¹
Prices (product feed)	Up to $198 for the priciest items, e.g. the Tana 14K Gold Ring Set¹
Low-priced jewelry (product feed)	Kids' bracelets from $10¹
Gold pieces (product page)	'14k gold plated sterling silver'; no plating thickness⁸
Product names	Plated pieces named '14K Gold' (e.g. 'Vivian 14K Gold Crystal Earring Set')⁷
Home page wording	'14k and 18k gold' pieces 'that will last you a lifetime'¹¹
Other bases (product pages)	Gold-plated brass; gold-plated zinc¹⁴
Kids' headband	Acrylic and gold-plated zinc¹⁵
Ring with no metal named	'Joy Pop' cocktail ring: materials listed as enamel and cubic zirconia only¹³
Plating thickness	Not given on the product pages we read^{7,8,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19}
Stones	Cubic zirconia named as such⁷
Moissanite (product feed)	Some demi-fine earrings come in cubic zirconia or moissanite, named as such¹
Diamonds	None in its product feed¹
Rings (product feed)	Sold, including ring sets¹
Nickel	'Hypoallergenic certified nickel-free, lead-free, cadmium-free'³
Sourcing policy	None found^3,9,11,25,26

Payment

The store runs on Shopify¹¹ and accepts PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay and all major credit cards³. Orders are charged when you place them, including pre-sale and custom items³. We found no installment plan, but with its priciest items at $198 that item doesn’t count for this store¹.

All details we checked

Payment methods	PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay and major credit cards³
Checkout platform (page code)	Shopify¹¹
When you're charged	At purchase, including pre-sale and custom items³

What customers say

BaubleBar has no shops of its own³, so Google’s points go to Trustpilot, where Google shows a 4-star rating from 648 reviews²⁰. Trustpilot’s summary says customers praise a prompt, helpful customer service team²⁹, and also that some earrings and custom pieces arrived smaller than expected, showed early signs of wear or ran into shipping problems³⁰. BaubleBar is BBB accredited, with 69 complaints in the last 3 years and 37 in the last 12 months²⁴; we’re still checking its BBB grade by hand. PissedConsumer shows 12 reviews averaging 2.7, citing customer service, cancellations and delivery³¹; Thingtesting shows 4.4 from 123 reviews³².

Complaints recur: a bracelet that ‘lost stones after only a few wears’²², earrings that left green marks after a morning²³, and a Yelp reviewer who received an empty, open package³³. A Threads post warns that BaubleBar ‘DOES NOT warranty their products’³⁴. On Reddit, one commenter would ‘avoid BaubleBar if you can’³⁵, while another has had ‘no issues whatsoever’ with the regular line sold at Nordstrom²³; a Reviewed.com writer advises not wearing the pieces in the shower, to protect the gold plating³⁶.

All details we checked

Trustpilot	4 stars, 648 reviews (Google snippet of the Trustpilot page)²⁰
Trustpilot summary	Reviewers praise a prompt, helpful customer service team²⁹
Trustpilot summary	Some pieces arrived smaller than expected or showed early wear; shipping problems³⁰
BBB	Accredited; 69 complaints in 3 years, 37 in the last 12 months (grade not in the snippets)²⁴
PissedConsumer	12 reviews, average 2.7; customer service, cancellation and delivery issues³¹
Thingtesting	4.4 from 123 reviews³²
Lemon8 post	A bracelet 'lost stones after only a few wears'²²
Reddit, r/Ipsy	Earrings left green marks after a morning²³
Yelp	A reviewer received an empty, open package³³
Threads post	'Baublebar DOES NOT warranty their products', and no support line³⁴
Reddit, r/jewelry	One commenter: 'I would avoid BaubleBar if you can.'³⁵
Reddit, r/Ipsy (another commenter)	Regular BaubleBar, sold at Nordstrom, had 'no issues whatsoever with the quality'²³
Reviewed.com	Advises not wearing pieces in the shower, to protect the gold plating³⁶

Linked from BaubleBar’s own website, so these are the brand’s real accounts.

Alternatives to BaubleBar

Monica Vinader — Gold-vermeil and recycled-silver jewelry with 100-day returns and a 5-year warranty
TOUS — Silver, vermeil and 18k gold jewelry with a two-year warranty against manufacturing defects
Estella Bartlett — Gold- and silver-plated brass jewelry with 30 days to return and a one-year guarantee

BaubleBar FAQ

Is BaubleBar legit?

Yes, it’s a real company: BaubleBar Inc., based in New York City, on a domain registered in 2010^3,9,10. Its returns are easy — 30 days from shipping with a prepaid label² — but it offers no warranty beyond a 3-day check on arrival^2,3,4,5,6, and Google shows it at 4 stars from 648 reviews on Trustpilot²⁰.

Does BaubleBar sell real gold?

The gold pieces we checked are plated: ’14K Gold plated sterling silver’, gold-plated brass or gold-plated zinc, with no plating thickness given^{7,8,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19}. Product names such as ‘Vivian 14K Gold Crystal Earring Set’ leave out the word ‘plated’⁷.

Does BaubleBar have free returns?

Returns start in its Returns Portal, which gives you a prepaid return label², and BaubleBar’s own page descriptions promise ‘free returns’²¹. You have 30 days from the shipping date for a full refund to your original payment², but original shipping isn’t refunded², and custom, made-to-order and final-sale items can’t be returned².

Does BaubleBar have a warranty?

We found none^2,3,4,5,6. Its quality guarantee covers only pieces that arrive ‘less than perfect’: send a photo to [email protected] within 3 business days³.

Who owns BaubleBar?

The site is run by BaubleBar Inc.⁹. Its LinkedIn page names Amy Jain and Daniella Yacobovsky as the founders²⁷, and press profiles call Amy Jain co-founder and CEO²⁸; the pages we read on the site name neither^{3,6,9,11,25,26}.

Where is BaubleBar located, and where does it ship from?

BaubleBar is based in New York City and ships all orders from its facility in New Jersey³; its terms give the address 1115 Broadway, 5th Floor, New York⁹.

Does BaubleBar have a store?

Not of its own: it sells through other retailers, including a shop-in-shop at FAO Schwarz in New York City³, and its SugarFix by BaubleBar line is sold at Target³.

How do I contact BaubleBar?

Email [email protected] — agents work from 9am to 9pm EST³ — or use the contact form⁶; it aims to respond within 24 hours⁶. There’s no phone line³.

Does BaubleBar ship outside the US?

The FAQ data on its Shipping & Returns page says ‘We do not currently ship outside of the United States’⁴.

How long does BaubleBar take to ship?

Most in-stock items ship within 24–48 hours⁴; Standard delivery then takes 5–7 business days, Expedited 3–5 and Rush 2–3⁴. Custom pieces are made to order, with an expected ship date on the product page⁵.

How much is shipping at BaubleBar?

Standard shipping is free on US orders of $75 or more; below that it costs $8⁴. Expedited costs $12 and Rush $20⁴.

Is BaubleBar jewelry nickel-free?

BaubleBar says every product is hypoallergenic and certified nickel-free, lead-free and cadmium-free³.

Does BaubleBar take Afterpay?

Afterpay isn’t among the payment methods it lists: PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay and all major credit cards³.

How we score stores

The Trust Score adds up 100 points across six areas: identity & transparency (20), purchase protection (25), warranty & aftercare (15), product transparency (15), payment safety (10), reputation (15). Every point is tied to a fact we can link to, and the rules are the same for every store. Read the full methodology.

90+ Excellent · 75–89 Trustworthy · 60–74 Mostly reliable · below 60 Proceed with caution. Ratings from other platforms are summarized in our own words with a link; we don’t copy reviews.

Update history

Nov 3, 2026 — First published, before our editor’s review. Every fact checked against baublebar.com and the other sources listed below as they read that day.

About this review

Researched and written by the Trusted Jewelries team. Every fact is checked against its source by our software. Our editor, Valentina Di Roberto, hasn’t reviewed this Trust Check yet; once that’s done, the editor’s name and the review date will appear here. Stores can’t pay for a review or a score. Found a mistake or a policy that has changed? Tell us and we’ll correct it.

Sources

All pages were read on Nov 3, 2026. Store policies change — check the store’s current terms before you buy.

BaubleBar

59/100 · Proceed with caution

Best for: New York fashion-jewelry brand: plated, custom and licensed pieces at up to $198

Visit BaubleBar

We may earn a commission. It never changes the score.

Other stores we’ve checked

Monica Vinader71/100 · Mostly reliableBritish gold-vermeil and recycled-silver jewelry with 100-day returns and a 5-year warranty · Visit

TOUS60/100 · Mostly reliableSpanish jeweler since 1920: silver, vermeil and 18k gold, the teddy-bear brand · Visit

Estella Bartlett57/100 · Proceed with cautionGold- and silver-plated brass jewelry and gifts from a London brand, shipping to the US · Visit

Keyzar78/100 · TrustworthyEngagement rings with lab-grown or natural diamonds · Visit

Shane Co.78/100 · TrustworthyFamily-owned US jeweler since 1929: engagement rings, diamonds, pearls · Visit

How we check stores →

BaubleBar: Trust Check

Best for

Not ideal for

What we like

Watch out for

BaubleBar policies at a glance

How BaubleBar scores

Who is behind BaubleBar

How to reach BaubleBar

Returns & exchanges

Shipping & delivery

Warranty & care

What BaubleBar sells & what it costs

Payment

What customers say

Official social profiles

Alternatives to BaubleBar

BaubleBar FAQ

How we score stores

Update history

Sources